New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - My Review of a 8x32 EL; 8x30 SLC NEU and a 8x30 CL
  FAQ FAQ  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

Check GunBroker.com for SWFA's No Reserve and No Minimum bid firearm auctions.

My Review of a 8x32 EL; 8x30 SLC NEU and a 8x30 CL

 Post Reply Post Reply   Topic Search Topic Search  Topic Options Topic Options
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)     Back to Top Direct Link To This Post Posted: August/18/2011 at 21:04
stephen b View Drop Down
Optics GrassHopper
Optics GrassHopper


Joined: November/05/2009
Status: Offline
Points: 33
Note:-  Advance notice- this is a long review-

I posted this review over on the "Birdforum" site- in the binocular section. I thought I would also post it here.


This is a review of the 3 binoculars that Swarovski makes in the 30 and 32 mm size- The 8x32 EL, the 8x30 SLC NEU and the new 8x30 CL. This is not the highest level of binocular that Swarovski makes. That category is reserved for the recently released, just this year- the Swarovision and the SLC HD. But these are the best that Swarovski offers in 30 and 32 mm at this time.





I am reviewing newly purchased binoculars. The 8x32 EL and the 8x30 SLC had a manufactured date of 2010 and the CL was manufactured in 2011. This a personal review that is based on my personal empirical observations using my eyes and my hands. No specialized instruments were used -other than a tripod/-viewing platform.

I tested the binoculars by viewing from the second floor and my back deck of my house. From this point, I have a view across the Mckenzie River Valley here in Oregon. I can look across the valley and see the hillside across at about 2.5 miles in distance. So I can see from 1 ft to 2.5 miles +. I have a wide variety of items to focus on to test a binocular for- FOV, image sharpness, clarity, image color saturation and rendition and also contrast. These include tree trunks, bare branches and foliage on evergreens and deciduous trees and grasslands and rock formations across the valley. There is an active logging operation going on across the valley.  I can view the river down below with a beaver den along one bank. I can observe a # of different birds from small song birds to Osprey's, Turkey Vultures, Blue Herons, ducks, geese, etc.

Here is a couple pics:





All of this gives me a wide variety of color and contrast to test the image quality of a binocular. Along with this, I have a # of different specific focal points that I use in this setting to regularly focus on to use as reference points.  I looked at the binoculars during all times of day and different lighting conditions including bright and low light and cloudy and sunny conditions.

 Some Basic specs on the binoculars:

8x32 EL

Price:     $1639 (on sale from reg. price of $1929
FOV         420 ft. at 1000 yds.
Weight      21.9 oz
Eye Relief  15mm
close focus 7 ft.

8x30 SLC NEU

Price:     $849 (on sale from reg. price of $1149
FOV         408 ft. at 1000 yds.
Weight      20.8 oz
Eye Relief  15mm
close focus 13 ft.

8x30 CL

Price:     $929
FOV         372 ft. at 1000 yds.
Weight      17.6 oz
Eye Relief  15mm
close focus 9.8 ft.

Observations and review:

I will first give a summary of where I ranked these in a few basic categories and then will give a discussion and summary.

Ergonomics (fit and overall handling)

  Rank order- 1. EL 2. CL 3. SLC

Build "Sturdiness "robustness" if you will

  Rank order- 1. SLC 2. I would say tie with the EL and CL

Focus (Knob and use)

  Rank order- 1. EL 2. CL 3. SLC

Diopter (position, build ,use)

  Rank order- 1. SLC 2. EL 3. CL

Eye relief

  Rank Order- All Equal- all listed at 15mm and all was adequate for me and my glasses

FOV

  Rank order- 1. EL 2. SLC 3. CL

Optic Image Quality:

 A. Sharpness/ clarity

     Rank order- 1. EL 2. SLC 3. CL

 B. Resolution of detail (using my eyes)

     Rank order- 1. EL 2. SLC 3. CL

 C. Brightness (summary of all times day- so includes low light)

     Rank order- All were pretty good in this test-
        1. EL 2. a tie-  SLC and CL

D.  Image Colors- (True Rendition and Saturation)

      Rank order- 1. EL 2. SLC 3. CL

E.  Image Contrast

      Rank order- 1. EL 2. SLC 3. CL

F. Image "Sweet Spot" size

      Rank order- 1. EL 2. SLC 3. CL

G. Edge to edge sharpness/ performance

      Rank order- 1. SLC 2. EL 3. CL

H. CA (Chromatic Aberration) ** Footnote- I do not have a problem with CA myself and I did look for this and found a little here- minor. The EL was a little worse at the edge compared to the other 2, but this very well might be due to its large FOV. In the cent none of them were a big problem. The SLC NEU seemed to control CA very well and the CL did a good job also.

      Rank order- To me-  All 3 binoculars overall tie as far as the center axis with the SLC and the CL having a slight edge over the EL in regards to edge CA.


My Final overall Ranking of these 30 and 32 MM Swarovski binoculars. This is in regards to my  overall Optical and Mechanical summary review.

  1. 8x32 EL
 
  2. 8x30 SLC NEU

  3. 8x30 CL

Discussion and summary opinion:

This discussion will mostly focus on the new 8x30 CL binocular; as the 8x30 SLC NEU and the 8x32 EL have been out for a while and have been used & reviewed quite a bit. They (the SLC and EL) are about at the end of their run as models. In fact the SLC NEU in any configuration has stopped production and IMO it is only a mater of time that the same can be said about the 8x32 EL- since all other EL's are no longer made and have been upgraded by the Swarovision. Hopefully in a matter of time there will be a 8x30 SLC HD and a 8x32 SV- but who knows.

So to get started with my opinion and explanation of my rankings above- first of all it was my opinion that the EL was quite a bit better than the other 2 and to me that makes sense. I have tested the SLC and the EL in this size before and that was my conclusion then and it is the same thing I found with these samples. I know that Swarovski has said in the past (and I have had their techs tell me the same thing) that the glass and the coatings are the same- only difference is the housing. But, that is just not what testing bears out. I have had a rep from one of the big optic sellers (who does and has had a # of Swarovski's) tell me that there was a definite difference in the resolution between the EL and the SLC. That is what I also found to be true over the last few days with these samples.

The 8x32 EL is considered by many to be one of the all time great 8x32's. I certainly would have to say that it is in that category. It may be debatable (in whose eyes and hands) as to which optic maker makes the best 8x32 (Swarovski; Zeiss; Leica: Nikon- etc.)- but the Swaro 8x32 EL is right in the thick of that discussion. It just has a wonderful ergonomic fe
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)     Back to Top Direct Link To This Post Posted: August/19/2011 at 17:26
coyote95 View Drop Down
Optics Professional
Optics Professional
Avatar

Joined: January/24/2009
Location: michigan
Status: Offline
Points: 799
thanks for your review     nice pictures Smile
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)     Back to Top Direct Link To This Post Posted: October/17/2011 at 06:32
IanSmith View Drop Down
Optics GrassHopper
Optics GrassHopper
Avatar

Joined: October/17/2011
Location: UK
Status: Offline
Points: 1
wow, quite impresing
 Post Reply Post Reply
  Share Topic   

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Similar Threads: "My Review of a 8x32 EL; 8x30 SLC NEU and a 8x30 CL"
Subject Author Forum Replies Last Post
My Review of a 8x32 EL; 8x30 SLC NEU and a 8x30 CL stephen b Binoculars 0
Swarovski CL 8x30 vs EL 8x32 BobH Binoculars 8
Swarovski: 8x30 SLC vs 8x32 EL pedi Binoculars 1
Swaro SLC 8x30 neu FS skywalker Optics For Sale 1
Swaro CL 8x30 or Leica Ultravid 8x32?? nyrifleman Binoculars 9
Leica 8x32 BR vs Swaro 8x30 SLC ? tjsshl Binoculars 16
SOLD: SLC 8x30 Swaro Binos yellowdog Optics For Sale 0
Swarovski 8x30 SLC Binoculars niles coyote Optics For Sale 1
Swarovski 8x30 SLC binoculars Nitrosteel Binoculars 1
Swarovski 8x30 slc binaculars little cleo Binoculars 0


This page was generated in 0.063 seconds.